Magic Kingdom: Be Our Guest

Image: HarshLight, Flickr (license)

Location: Fantasyland

It’s been nearly seven years since the Beast first opened the castle to his hungry subjects, and the demand for an invitation (read: an advance dining reservation) has only grown since then. Diners walking up the stone path to the castle will take their meals in one of three premier locations: the story’s iconic and beautiful ballroom, an elegant gallery, and a somewhat dilapidated, if intriguing West Wing.

Here, the appeal is not only glimpsing elements of a familiar story, but feeling immersed in the story as well. The castle is somewhat removed from other buildings within Fantasyland’s borders (or, at the very least, made to feel that way through forced perspective) and flanked by other recognizable landmarks from the film: Belle’s cottage, where the village-girl-turned-princess hosts regular storytelling sessions, and Gaston’s Tavern. Guests can interact with both Belle and Gaston outside Be Our Guest, then venture inside the castle for a private reception with the Beast during dinner—the only time of day when the restaurant provides full table service.

Of course, it’s worth pointing out that Be Our Guest has relatively little competition in the Magic Kingdom, making it a natural and appealing choice for those looking for something a little extra with their meals. Though Cinderella’s Royal Table and the Crystal Palace both offer character dining at similar price points, neither of them use Be Our Guest’s specific detailing to fully immerse diners in a fairytale experience, while other casual dining options like Tony’s Town Square and the Plaza Restaurant aren’t anywhere close to providing competition at this level.

Universal Orlando: The Three Broomsticks and The Leaky Cauldron

Image: trickofthelight, Flickr (license)

Location: Hogsmeade (Islands of Adventure) and Diagon Alley (Universal Studios Florida)

Call it a testament to the convincing quality of Universal’s Wizarding World of Harry Potter that it’s nearly impossible to declare a true winner between their two primary dining experiences: Hogsmeade’s The Three Broomsticks and Diagon Alley’s The Leaky Cauldron. Both hold a significant place in the book and film series, both offer relatively similar food (The Three Broomsticks skews a bit more American, with spareribs and smoked turkey legs on the menu, while The Leaky Cauldron tends toward decidedly British dishes like bangers and mash and Guinness stew), and both are perfectly situated within their respective worlds.

In fact, picking one or the other may come down to personal preference alone. Would you rather feel like a Hogwarts student on leave from class, sneaking down to the pub for your first taste of Butterbeer? Or would you rather step into a world where escaped Azkaban convicts lurk in the shadows and grainy moving snapshots of ‘Wanted’ posters?

The key thing to note here is that neither location provides diners with the kind of high-level table service experience they might otherwise find at the Lost Continent’s Mythos Restaurant or Magic Kingdom’s Be Our Guest. From the sparse décor to the plain fare, everything at these two restaurants feels more realistic than theatrical—and that works to its own advantage. For those looking to spot key props from the Harry Potter films (fun fact: The Three Broomsticks restaurant predates the film set constructed for Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince) or just seeking a refuge away from the Muggle world, a more immersive experience can’t be found.

Tokyo DisneySea: Magellan’s

Image: Disney

Location: Mediterranean Harbor Port

Don’t take Magellan’s low place on this list as a sign that it’s somehow subpar to the other restaurants mentioned here. On the contrary, it holds a superlative rating among theme park diners, many of whom have frequently crowned the Mediterranean club as one of the best eateries the Disney Parks has to offer.

Magellan’s isn’t centered around original attractions, Greek mythology, or beloved films and franchises. Instead, it pulls elements from history and gives them a creative twist to make guests feel as though they’ve stepped into something both historical and otherworldly. According to the official story, the lounge and table service restaurant is part of an exclusive club founded by Portuguese explorer Ferdinand Magellan, most famous for coordinating the first circumnavigation of the Earth in the early 16th century. Together with other notable explorers, Magellan formed the S.E.A. (Society of Explorers and Adventurers) and christened the restaurant as their meeting place.

Attractions, buildings, props, and art tied to this mysterious and illustrious society can be found in various Disney properties, including Hong Kong Disneyland’s Mystic Manor and Aulani Resort’s children’s club. There’s no better place to soak up the history of S.E.A. than at Magellan’s, however, where guests can enjoy pre-dinner cocktails in the top-level lounge, eat under an exquisitely-decorated dome and globe in the main dining room, or elect to take their meals in a “secret” wine cellar.

Like Mythos, there are no nearby attractions or characters offered here, making Magellan’s feel like more of an adults-only destination. Unlike Mythos, however, this rates as a fine dining experience over a casual one, while Disney’s layered backstory ushers its guests into an experience that feels as real as it does magical.

***

What theme park restaurant transports you to a different world or makes you feel immersed in a favorite story? Are you planning to dine at any of the above restaurants during your next vacation to Disney or Universal?